I should probably leave this alone, but I just can’t help myself.
Laura Capitano, a features columnist for the (Jacksonville) Florida Times-Union, apparently didn’t have a very good experience on a recent visit to Memphis.
In one of her columns, posted on The Commercial Appeal’s web site yesterday, she describes Memphis as "Nashville’s dirty, drunken cousin" and goes on to chronicle a litany of our fair city’s shortcomings.
I wouldn’t disagree with a lot of what she said. Graffiti? Yep, we've got it. Drunks on Beale Street? Sure, why not? Taxi drivers cursing our honorable mayor? Well, it doesn’t surprise me if they do.
My problem is hearing that type of criticism from someone who lives in Jacksonville.
You see, I lived in Jacksonville myself for two years (and worked at the Times-Union), which I think allows me to make a more informed judgment about her town than she was able to make after having a cup of coffee in our town.
And let me tell you, Jacksonville isn’t exactly Florida’s garden spot..
People from elsewhere in the state have long joked about handing Jacksonville over to Georgia.
There’s a saying that the St. Johns River flows north because it’s the quickest way out of Jacksonville.
If a hurricane ever hit Jacksonville, it’s debatable that anyone would be able to tell the difference.
Does Jacksonville have an image problem? Let’s just say that during my time there, I told people I lived in North St. Augustine. (OK, not really. But that’s just because I didn’t think of it then.)
Capitano was apparently perturbed because someone threw up in the lobby of the hotel where she was staying. Big deal. With the possible exception of the Landing, just about everything I used to see in downtown Jacksonville made me want to hurl.
Capitano also wrote that the major tourist attractions in Memphis "stand among blight and fast-food chains, and are rather inaccessible to tourists."
Fair enough. But Jacksonville doesn’t have any tourist attractions. It does have plenty of blight, though.
Hey, I’m the first to admit that Memphis needs to clean up its act. I’m frustrated all the time that there’s not more progress along that front.
But I just find Capitano’s "cleanlier and soberer than thou" attitude a little hard to take. Living where she lives, she’s in no position to throw stones.